Confirming the Chandrayan 3 Landing
And Debunking DITRH's (David Weiss) Nonsense
And Debunking DITRH's (David Weiss) Nonsense
|
|
I am getting A LOT of PMs from people from India thanking me for defending their country's great achievement. They are really infuriated with flat earthers disrespect!! Most of these likes here on this post of mine are from India
1. DITRH Exposed
|
|
FUNNY Right After He Emailed Me He Updated His Video with a Pinned Comment.
But this was THREE DAYS AFTER THE VIDEO WAS RELEASED??
But this was THREE DAYS AFTER THE VIDEO WAS RELEASED??
SCROLL DOWN
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
YES I CAN BECAUSE THERE IS NO WAY THE P1000 will be able to magnify the image that far in space
|
|
3. Clearly Flat Earthers Did NOT GET DITRH's MEMO!!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
4. Apparently DITRH did not get his own memo as this was recorded AFTER his post!!
DITRH EXPOSES HIMSELF!
DITRH Teaching NONSENSE to Greenwich High School Students DITRH Exposed - Teaching Nonsense to Greenwich High School Perhaps more disturbing than his lies about Chandrayaan is that he is teaching this (and other flat earth nonsense) to summer school students at Greenwich High School!
DITRH EXPOSES HIMSELF!
DITRH Teaching NONSENSE to Greenwich High School Students DITRH Exposed - Teaching Nonsense to Greenwich High School Perhaps more disturbing than his lies about Chandrayaan is that he is teaching this (and other flat earth nonsense) to summer school students at Greenwich High School!
4. Anyone with Half a Brain Could See from the Livestream that Image was just an animation used a visual aid to see the landing from velocity and altitude data. It was never intended to be actual footage, because they did not have a camera crew waiting on the moon...LOL
Here is one more from mission control. On the left is the ACTUAL camera filming the moons surface. THOSE were the ONLY images that were reported to be real.
5. Actual Footage from the Actual Cameras
The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) late on Sunday completed its first Moon- bound manoeuvre, a day after Chandrayaan-3 was guided into an elliptical lunar orbit.
The spacecraft's altitude at Apolune (farthest point from Moon) was reduced from 18,074km to 4,313km.
ISRO released the first images of the Moon which were captured by India's third unmanned Moon mission, Chandrayaan-3.
10 People Watched the Launch on Location
The spacecraft's altitude at Apolune (farthest point from Moon) was reduced from 18,074km to 4,313km.
ISRO released the first images of the Moon which were captured by India's third unmanned Moon mission, Chandrayaan-3.
10 People Watched the Launch on Location
|
|
The full landing sequence of #Chandrayaan3
This footage was a result undo the rame blending from the original video and then upscaled the images with AI.
The video is at 120x playback speed, in reality this took about 66 minutes.
Sequence Footage from Camera 4 of the lunar surface as the spacecraft comes in and approaches for landing.
Interesting part is when it begins to descend, with its careful maneuvering and hovering. You know it is in this phase because the spacecraft changes orientation and then pauses for a moment as it surveys the landing site and adjusting a little here and there and at the end we get a little flash of those thrusters kicking up the regolith.
This footage was a result undo the rame blending from the original video and then upscaled the images with AI.
The video is at 120x playback speed, in reality this took about 66 minutes.
Sequence Footage from Camera 4 of the lunar surface as the spacecraft comes in and approaches for landing.
Interesting part is when it begins to descend, with its careful maneuvering and hovering. You know it is in this phase because the spacecraft changes orientation and then pauses for a moment as it surveys the landing site and adjusting a little here and there and at the end we get a little flash of those thrusters kicking up the regolith.
The Spacecrafts time on the surface is limited to the sunlight, when the sun goes down the spacecraft might not wake up again.
It begins by deploying the ramp for the rover, and the rover deploys a solar panel and is lowered down the ramp. There are actually wires that are used to slowly lower this down to the lunar surface.
It begins by deploying the ramp for the rover, and the rover deploys a solar panel and is lowered down the ramp. There are actually wires that are used to slowly lower this down to the lunar surface.
The rover spent a day or so at the bottom of the ramp, probably checking systems out and charging its batteries before it finally proceeded out beyond the immediate vicinity of the lander and turned itself to align with the sun. That vertical thing coming up is the solar panels. And it turns to align its solar panels with the sun.
Double Swing Arm Suspension Capable of traversing rocks 5 centimeters. They estimate the depression to be 10 cm, which seems to be well within its capability.
|
|
69 degrees south. Lunar polar orbits. Solar panels on sides.
Gotta know you can get power. Dark crater and done.
Precision landing. So can have power.
Earth and sun low on horizon.
Image taken at lunar noon. Shadows perfectly lining up.
Orientation carefully considered. Hover and rotation.
Gotta know you can get power. Dark crater and done.
Precision landing. So can have power.
Earth and sun low on horizon.
Image taken at lunar noon. Shadows perfectly lining up.
Orientation carefully considered. Hover and rotation.
I found this information to answer your question (some of which have been mentioned so I will put it all in one).
Here is why it is not color:
1. Rover's camera are only for navigation purpose (NavCam)
2. Rover is not directly connected to ground station, it is with the lander so bigger sized photo will be headache
3. Rover has experimental instruments onboard, photo is not primary objective
4. No colour on the moon surface so why bother anyway with a colour camera that requires a higher data rate (more bandwidth) to download
5. Black and white allows for higher resolution for a given amount of data. So if you have a restricted bandwidth you'll get higher resolution with B&W than with color anyway.
Here is why it is not color:
1. Rover's camera are only for navigation purpose (NavCam)
2. Rover is not directly connected to ground station, it is with the lander so bigger sized photo will be headache
3. Rover has experimental instruments onboard, photo is not primary objective
4. No colour on the moon surface so why bother anyway with a colour camera that requires a higher data rate (more bandwidth) to download
5. Black and white allows for higher resolution for a given amount of data. So if you have a restricted bandwidth you'll get higher resolution with B&W than with color anyway.
|
|
Goal of this mission is Research, NOT Pictures!
Indian people REALLY into this mission. Focused on practical things. Reusing rockets. Did it on an extreme budget.
Signals Sent from Rover to Lander than to NASA Deep space network than to ISRO ground station.
Indian people REALLY into this mission. Focused on practical things. Reusing rockets. Did it on an extreme budget.
Signals Sent from Rover to Lander than to NASA Deep space network than to ISRO ground station.
Sample of Tests Performed from Both Vikram and Rover
On its part, the lander too will carry out the tasks assigned to it with its payloads: Chandra’s Surface Thermophysical Experiment (ChaSTE) to measure the thermal conductivity and temperature; Instrument for Lunar Seismic Activity (ILSA) for measuring the seismicity around the landing site; RAMBHA Langmuir Probe (LP) to estimate the plasma density and its variations.
Lunar Surface Poor Conductor so temperature drops to zero quickly. Helps to predict if water is to be found.
Lunar Surface Poor Conductor so temperature drops to zero quickly. Helps to predict if water is to be found.
|
|
|
Rover Tests - Spectroscopy apparently doesn't need a container!
According to ISRO, the moon rover has Alpha Particle X-ray Spectrometer (APXS) and Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscope (LIBS) for deriving the elemental composition in the vicinity of the landing site.
APXS - Provides Complementary data and confirms the elements detected with LIBS
LIBS - Uses high energy laser to determine the composition of the materials.
According to ISRO, the moon rover has Alpha Particle X-ray Spectrometer (APXS) and Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscope (LIBS) for deriving the elemental composition in the vicinity of the landing site.
APXS - Provides Complementary data and confirms the elements detected with LIBS
LIBS - Uses high energy laser to determine the composition of the materials.
|
|
|
Temperature as low as -130 degrees Celsius = -202 F (looking for Hydrogren)
|
|
LAST TEST WAS CONCLUSIVE!!
Sources also say that both the Lander and Rover Confirmed that Daylight Does Indeed Come from the Sun on the Lunar Surface.
Sources also say that both the Lander and Rover Confirmed that Daylight Does Indeed Come from the Sun on the Lunar Surface.
6. Polish Astronomer Verifies Orbit
A group of private astronomers using the Polish ROTUZ (Panoptes-4) telescope spotted the spacecraft cruising through space. Sybilla Technologies, the company operating the telescope, shared a video capturing Chandrayaan-3 as a small dot amidst the vastness of space and stars on Tuesday.
Scott Tilley, a member of the observation team, provided a trajectory update on Wednesday, mentioning that the spacecraft passed through its first apogee of the new orbit, spending many hours in deep space, drifting through his field of view.
Scott Tilley, a member of the observation team, provided a trajectory update on Wednesday, mentioning that the spacecraft passed through its first apogee of the new orbit, spending many hours in deep space, drifting through his field of view.
Landing Location Matches Descent Videos
Chandrayan 2 Spots Landing!!
Chandrayan 2 Spots Landing!!
69 Degrees -- On Earth 66'.30" is Artic Circle
|
|
Scott Tilley and Other Amateur Astronomers
Scott Tilley Tracked Chandrayaan 3 all the way out.
Textbook, as they claimed, only minor discrepancies (clearly rounding the clock). Open and transparent.
I THINK FLAT EARTHERS LIKE DAVE WILL GO "RADIO SILENT" ON THIS ONE.
Scott Tilley Tracked Chandrayaan 3 all the way out.
Textbook, as they claimed, only minor discrepancies (clearly rounding the clock). Open and transparent.
I THINK FLAT EARTHERS LIKE DAVE WILL GO "RADIO SILENT" ON THIS ONE.
|
|
Chandrayaan-3 - Landed!
Soothing tones of Vikram lander on the Moon!
Soothing tones of Vikram lander on the Moon!
|
Recording Doppler Data
|
Proof - Comparing his Doppler Data to JPL Horizons - MATCH!!
The spacecraft is broadcasting some known frequency and you are simply measuring this signal and seeing a Doppler shift that is consistent with the signal coming from the moon.
ISRO posts trajectory data to JPL Horizons (an international repository of rocks in space, moon etc). Scott Tilley and others recorded data with his own antenna from the lander and compared to what the Moon Doppler should be. They are the same.
The Doppler effect is an apparent change in the frequency of a satellite transmitter when it approaches, passes overhead or moves away, which in turn helps in calculating the distance between a satellite transmitting from space and a radio receiver on the ground.
For assessing the latest position of Chandrayaan-3, Scott employs Doppler frequency shift data and then plots it on a graph with respect to time in order to achieve a Doppler curve.
The Doppler shift at this point is due to the radial velocity of the moon relative to the earth, and specifically the observer's position on the surface of the earth. There's a diurnal component on top of slower day to day trends due to the orbit of the moon.
Scott basically puts his location into JPL Horizons, so he can pull the radial velocity data from his observer site to generate that graph. So this way it has the topocentric motion baked in to graph the expected Doppler shift.
Scott Did Detailed Doppler Analysis confirming the Artemis Mission too!
https://github.com/ScottTilley/Artemis1/blob/main/Artemis%20I%20Tracking%20_RFI_SEE_TILLEY.pdf
The spacecraft is broadcasting some known frequency and you are simply measuring this signal and seeing a Doppler shift that is consistent with the signal coming from the moon.
ISRO posts trajectory data to JPL Horizons (an international repository of rocks in space, moon etc). Scott Tilley and others recorded data with his own antenna from the lander and compared to what the Moon Doppler should be. They are the same.
The Doppler effect is an apparent change in the frequency of a satellite transmitter when it approaches, passes overhead or moves away, which in turn helps in calculating the distance between a satellite transmitting from space and a radio receiver on the ground.
For assessing the latest position of Chandrayaan-3, Scott employs Doppler frequency shift data and then plots it on a graph with respect to time in order to achieve a Doppler curve.
The Doppler shift at this point is due to the radial velocity of the moon relative to the earth, and specifically the observer's position on the surface of the earth. There's a diurnal component on top of slower day to day trends due to the orbit of the moon.
Scott basically puts his location into JPL Horizons, so he can pull the radial velocity data from his observer site to generate that graph. So this way it has the topocentric motion baked in to graph the expected Doppler shift.
Scott Did Detailed Doppler Analysis confirming the Artemis Mission too!
https://github.com/ScottTilley/Artemis1/blob/main/Artemis%20I%20Tracking%20_RFI_SEE_TILLEY.pdf
|
|
https://www.isro.gov.in/chandrayaan3_gallery.html
Summary
1. ISRO has no track record of deception, in fact they just launched another probe to study the sun.
2. 10,000 People Watched and witness the Chandrayaan 3 launch
3. Detailed Videos on approaching moon and landing
4. Confirmation of Vikram from Chanderyaan 2 matches footage from landing video
5. Real Images of Rover, moon surface and of Vikram from Rover with no proof whatsoever fake
6. Many tests performed with extreme details and some unexpected results.
7. Signals can be received by anyone with the equipment and knowledge to do so at frequencies stated
8. Doppler Data can be recorded and compared to JPL horizons or other sources to confirm Vikram on the moon
9. No flat earther has shown ONE SHRED of Evidence the Landing was fake.
10. DITRH exposed contradicting himself. Calling him a liar is a Forgone Conclusion, because you HAVE TO Lie to FLERF!
11. Mission showed with TWO different forms (X-ray and Laser induced) that Spectroscopy DOES NOT NEED A CONTAINER!
If this was a Jury Trial Who Would Win??
A Mountain of Evidence Vs "It's Fake"
1. ISRO has no track record of deception, in fact they just launched another probe to study the sun.
2. 10,000 People Watched and witness the Chandrayaan 3 launch
3. Detailed Videos on approaching moon and landing
4. Confirmation of Vikram from Chanderyaan 2 matches footage from landing video
5. Real Images of Rover, moon surface and of Vikram from Rover with no proof whatsoever fake
6. Many tests performed with extreme details and some unexpected results.
7. Signals can be received by anyone with the equipment and knowledge to do so at frequencies stated
8. Doppler Data can be recorded and compared to JPL horizons or other sources to confirm Vikram on the moon
9. No flat earther has shown ONE SHRED of Evidence the Landing was fake.
10. DITRH exposed contradicting himself. Calling him a liar is a Forgone Conclusion, because you HAVE TO Lie to FLERF!
11. Mission showed with TWO different forms (X-ray and Laser induced) that Spectroscopy DOES NOT NEED A CONTAINER!
If this was a Jury Trial Who Would Win??
A Mountain of Evidence Vs "It's Fake"
